As the Spanish-speaking population of the east side continued to grow, so did the need for a church of their own. In the 1950s, the people of Mayfair sent a letter to the archbishop in San Francisco, who oversaw the Catholic institutions in the area. The letter, requesting that a church offering Spanish-language services be established in Mayfair, had over a thousand signatures. Their request was denied; it was the view of the archbishop that the people could simply attend services at the existing parishes nearby.